Arweave, Beeple, Check My NFT, Disappearing NFTs, Interplanetary File System, IPFS gateway, IPFS hash, IPFS Hosting, Jonty Wareing, JSON file, Makersplace, NFT art, NFT Criticism, NFT sales, NFTs, Nifty Gateway, Non-fungible token (NFT), Non-fungible tokens, Pak

On the week of March 7 through the 13th, the term “NFT†touched an all-time record high in terms of popular search queries according to Google Trends (GT). The highest score is 100 and this week, GT shows interest has dwindled a hair down to 97. Meanwhile, while the NFT hype affects the cryptocurrency and blockchain community, not everyone is thrilled with this technology. Some critics think NFT tech needs to be more robust in order for collectibles to last more than a decade without them disappearing.

The Rift Between NFT Hype and NFT Criticism

Over the last few weeks, the NFT craze has jumped to new levels as people have sold artwork for millions of dollars, unique audio recordings of farts have been tokenized, and even blockchain-backed signature dance moves are NFTs. And of course, by now everyone has heard about Beeple, the digital artist who sold an NFT via Christie’s auction house for a whopping $69 million. This sale propelled NFT mania to new heights, and Christie’s auction invoked Sotheby’s to partner with an artist named Pak.

The mysterious digital artist Pak was selling an NFT on Makersplace called “Metarift.†An NFT art collector named “888†placed a bid on Metarift for $888,888 on March 19. The following day, the bid had been upped to $904,413 by a bidder named “Danny.†The auction ended on Pak’s latest NFT artwork sale on Saturday at 12:30 p.m. (PST) with Danny’s winning bid.

Arweave, Beeple, Check My NFT, Disappearing NFTs, Interplanetary File System, IPFS gateway, IPFS hash, IPFS Hosting, Jonty Wareing, JSON file, Makersplace, NFT art, NFT Criticism, NFT sales, NFTs, Nifty Gateway, Non-fungible token (NFT), Non-fungible tokens, Pak
As of 3:30 p.m. (EST), Pak’s “Metarift†NFT’s highest bid was for $904,413 by a bidder named Danny who now owns the NFT.

Despite all the mega-auctions and all the celebrities joining in on the fun, non-fungible token (NFT) assets have come under a lot of criticism. Bitcoin.com’s newsdesk discussed the topic of NFT immutability which has been the industry’s biggest weak point so far. In that editorial tokenized NFT tweets were deleted and artwork was replaced with other images.

On March 17, the Twitter user Jonty Wareing told his 6,932 followers how non-fungible tokens reference the media people are purchasing today. His first tweet went viral with more than 27,000 likes and close to 10,000 retweets.

File Vanishes from the Host ‘Your Token Is Now Worthless’

He discussed a sale of an original Beeple sold on Nifty Gateway, and detailed how the Beeple JSON file was hosted on Nifty Gateway’s servers. Wareing then explained how the NFT is also hosted on Cloudinary. “So if Nifty goes bust, your token is now worthless,†Wareing said. “It refers to nothing. This can’t be changed,†he added. Then Wareing also talked about files that are using the Interplanetary File System (IPFS) as well. In this tweet, he specifically discussed the Beeple sold by Christie’s which is connected to IPFS.

“So, well done for referring to IPFS – it references the specific file rather than a URL that might break,†Wareing continued and showed the metadata link to an IPFS gateway run by Makersplace. But if something happened to Makersplace, then once again, the link may be useless over time. “You might say ‘Just refer to the IPFS hash in both places’†Wareing added. But further scorned that “IPFS only serves files as long as a node in the IPFS network intentionally keeps hosting it.â€

Wareing also said:

Twitter Account Dubbed Check My NFT Discovers Current NFT Flaws in the Wild

Moreover, he also tweeted about an example of the issue happening today and said “NFT’s are built on an absolute house of cards constructed by the people selling them.†He claims the tech will be “broken†within a decade. The Twitter account called “Check My NFT†(@checkmynft) has also been tweeting about a bunch of missing art, and inaccessible NFT assets.

Arweave, Beeple, Check My NFT, Disappearing NFTs, Interplanetary File System, IPFS gateway, IPFS hash, IPFS Hosting, Jonty Wareing, JSON file, Makersplace, NFT art, NFT Criticism, NFT sales, NFTs, Nifty Gateway, Non-fungible token (NFT), Non-fungible tokens, Pak
The Twitter account called “Check My NFT†has been investigating the permanence issue with non-fungible token (NFT) assets.

In our last report, Check My NFT explained that metadata, URLs, and image files “should be backed by an immutable and permanent storage provider.†One way of doing this is leveraging IPFS2Arweave.com, which utilizes a project called Arweave.

Arweave, Beeple, Check My NFT, Disappearing NFTs, Interplanetary File System, IPFS gateway, IPFS hash, IPFS Hosting, Jonty Wareing, JSON file, Makersplace, NFT art, NFT Criticism, NFT sales, NFTs, Nifty Gateway, Non-fungible token (NFT), Non-fungible tokens, Pak
IPFS2Arweave.com leverages the Arweave network to store the files and also pin the NFT data to the Interplanetary File System.

The IPFS + Arweave solution claims to solve the permanence problem by using Arweave for storage and pinning the NFT data to the Interplanetary File System.

“IPFS is a popular P2P network for sharing data in a decentralized way, but it lacks one feature: Permanence. Content on the IPFS network can disappear. If no-one hosts the data, it could be lost forever,†the Arweave website details. “The Arweave blockchain can now store and pin files onto IPFS and keep them available permanently. This simple API takes an IPFS Hash, stores the data onto Arweave, and pins it to IPFS.â€

It will be interesting to see if NFT projects take the recent scrutiny seriously, and leverage immutable and permanent storage as Check My NFT and Arweave recommends. Projects going forward may work toward building stronger permanence models. Projects that have already minted million-dollar NFT works might want to make sure the non-fungible token assets are truly deemed immutable.

Meanwhile, other blockchain NFT solutions believe their distributed ledger protocol alone is reliable enough to preserve an NFT for centuries to come. Much of this NFT debate will still require the test of time or exposure to vulnerabilities.

What do you think about the NFT permanence problem? Let us know what you think about this subject in the comments section below.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. It is not a direct offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, or a recommendation or endorsement of any products, services, or companies. Bitcoin.com does not provide investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice. Neither the company nor the author is responsible, directly or indirectly, for any damage or loss caused or alleged to be caused by or in connection with the use of or reliance on any content, goods or services mentioned in this article.

RELATED NEWS

14 Years of Art for $500K: Youtuber Ali Spagnola Compiles All Her Free Paintings Into an NFT

In mid-January, Bitcoin.com’s newsdesk wrote about the popular artist and Youtuber, Alicia Dawn “Ali†Spagnola after she “accidentally got bitcoin rich†from her Free Paintings project. Since then, a great number of people told her to create a non-fungible token (NFT) asset with her artwork, so she decided to execute the idea after many requests. […]

Xem chi tiết: 14 Years of Art for $500K: Youtuber Ali Spagnola Compiles All Her Free Paintings Into an NFT

British auction house Christie’s Plans to Sell 9 Rare Cryptopunk NFTs Next Month 

Next month in New York, the popular auction house Christie’s plans to auction a rare lot of Cryptopunk non-fungible token (NFT) collectibles. The sample of work sold will be approximately nine rare Punks, courtesy of the project’s creators Larva Labs. Nine Rare Cryptopunks Going to Auction On May 13, 2021, the British auction house founded […]

Xem chi tiết: British auction house Christie’s Plans to Sell 9 Rare Cryptopunk NFTs Next Month 

NFTs Come to Live in Uquid Shop as NFTD

press release PRESS RELEASE. Uquid Shop, the largest digital asset eCommerce platform is ready to buy and sell digital art, Social & Digital Content, Copyright Products, and Digitals Products involving non-fungible tokens(NFT). Uquid non-fungible tokens are known as NFTD. Scheduled to take place in 2021, the Uquid NFTD project will be the first in the […]

Xem chi tiết: NFTs Come to Live in Uquid Shop as NFTD

Lifestyle and Entertainment Company Playboy Plans to Launch NFTs With Nifty Gateway

Playboy the American men’s lifestyle and entertainment magazine created by Hugh Hefner is joining the non-fungible token (NFT) craze. While the company used to mint Playboy collectible keys for fans to gain access to the mansion, Playboy now plans to offer collectibles in the cryptographic form. Playboy’s Chief Brand Officer: NFTs Present ‘an Enormous Business […]

Xem chi tiết: Lifestyle and Entertainment Company Playboy Plans to Launch NFTs With Nifty Gateway

Cryptowisser: 30 NFT Marketplaces Dominate the Market, but More Will Come as NFTs Continue to Boom

press release PRESS RELEASE. Leading Crypto comparison site, Cryptowisser have just announced their NFT marketplace list. The list details the current marketplaces that NFT Artists, collectors and traders can list, sell and buy non-fungible tokens on. With the recent hype and surge in the NFT space, different NFT niches are emerging and with those niches […]

Xem chi tiết: Cryptowisser: 30 NFT Marketplaces Dominate the Market, but More Will Come as NFTs Continue to Boom

Non-Fungible Token Sales Begin to Dive, NFT Interest Declines, Finance Author Highlights NFT Oversupply

Non-fungible token (NFT) assets and collectibles are starting to see sales decline and interest in NFTs is dropping as well. Additionally, it’s being said that an “oversupply of NFTs†may hurt the market, according to James Surowiecki the author of “The Wisdom of Crowds.†In 2021, non-fungible tokens have been all the rage and the […]

Xem chi tiết: Non-Fungible Token Sales Begin to Dive, NFT Interest Declines, Finance Author Highlights NFT Oversupply

Hip-Hop Star Snoop Dogg Says Bitcoin ‘Here to Stay’— Lauds NFTs for Creating Direct Connection Between Artists and Fans

Pioneering hip-hop artist and businessman, Snoop Dogg has said he believes in bitcoin, the (blockchain) technology behind the crypto asset and the global connection it creates. The celebrity adds that while he’s not “too caught up in the value of the coin,†he has been around long enough to “know it’s here to stay.†Not […]

Xem chi tiết: Hip-Hop Star Snoop Dogg Says Bitcoin ‘Here to Stay’— Lauds NFTs for Creating Direct Connection Between Artists and Fans

Study Highlights the Most Common NFT Scams Amid the Current Mainstream Hype

As non-fungible tokens (NFTs) are becoming a global phenomenon increasingly due to their mainstream adoption, there are also concerns about the surge of related scams. A recent study revealed the most common NFT scams that are spreading on the net. Suspicious Domain Registrations With ‘NFT’ Word Surged 250% in March 2021 According to the research […]

Xem chi tiết: Study Highlights the Most Common NFT Scams Amid the Current Mainstream Hype

Popular Bobblehead Manufacturer Funko Announces New Lineup of NFT Products

Topps Digital Towers Over NFT Universe With Upcoming Godzilla NFT Collectibles

Topps Digital Towers Over NFT Universe With Upcoming Godzilla Collectible Auction

Tron’s Justin Sun Unveils NFT Fund Aimed at Art Acquisition

Interest from China, Co-Mining and a Grayscale Trust Gives Filecoin’s Market Cap a Valuation Lift

Nilicoins, Rare Pepe and Curio Cards- A Look at the OG Collectibles That Started the NFT Madness

Italian Copyright Agency Selects Algorand to Create Over Four Million NFTs to Represent Author Rights

Iconic ‘Obey’ Street Artist Shepard Fairey to Auction an NFT Mural on Superrare

Other Articles